The New Civil War
The Confederacy did not seek to actually overthrow the government of Washington, DC. Rather, the Confederacy wanted out of the arrangement to do as it pleased. Will we shortly re-visit that old dissatisfaction?
Consider three maps please. The first map is the Confederate States.
The second map is the states that have adopted Right To Work Laws. In those states one cannot be forced to join a union as a condition of employment.
The third map is the Red Blue State Map. This reflects states that have been predominantly Republican or Democrat in the last few elections. By this point the reader may have already realized that that yes, they are all the same map! Now let’s look at the consequences of this long term split.
Abraham Lincoln was the first Republican President. The South declared secession during his first term. At that time, and until the 1960s, the Democrats had the ‘solid south.’ This control was due to poll taxes and other illegal devices to keep minority citizens from voting. In the 1960s that changed as Lyndon Johnson made Civil rights a Democrat Issue. The story of the Civil War was, like many wars, the story of a better industrialized North overcoming a much more rural South.
That industry was still in the North as unions began forming in the 1920s-30s. With little heavy industry in the South, unions were simply not a southern issue. Today it is a very serious issue. The combination of entrenched management’s failure to respond to market change (Ford, GM, Chrysler) coupled with high union demands has sent, for example, the entire new auto industry to the South.
Former economic backwaters like Alabama now sport billion dollar plants from Hyundai and Airbus, and their new workers. Notably, none are unionized. While Michigan’s Jeff Daniels begs industry to come to his native Michigan, it sports the highest unemployment of any state, over 15%.
California, the eighth largest economy in the world, larger than Russia, is bankrupt. Payments to government union workers are routinely in six digits. New York City continues to raise taxes on its few thousand that actually support the City.
Now the government is making subsidized jobs programs of former companies like GM. The giveaway of the company to the union, not the creditors, insures no one will invest heavily in such a union controlled venture ever again. Toyota just left the California GM venture to re-locate Tacoma production to the new plant in San Antonio.
As I write, Michigan and Nevada, union states, have managed to avoid the heavy taxes associated with the new health care legislation, thanks to their Senators. The question then becomes, just how long will the non subsidized workers in southern states support failed business models in the union shop states? Clearly business is locating in the South, not the North.
Rasmusssen reports that only 16% of voters approve of the job Congress is doing. The disapproval of the President is now eleven points higher than his approval ratings. Fifty-nine percent (59%) of U.S. voters believe that the current level of political anger in the country is higher than it was when George W. Bush was president. This finding is in perfect synch with what one would expect in a recession, anger is growing .
The longer this goes on, the subsidies, the handouts to failed business models in states and cities, the higher the dissatisfaction will be. The idea of a United States has considerable force but consider what happened recently in Quebec. The referendum took place in Quebec on October 30, 1995, and the motion to decide whether Quebec should secede from Canada was defeated by a very narrow margin of: 50.58% "No" to 49.42% "Yes".
No doubt the politicians in Washington, viewing the dissatisfaction in town hall meetings dismiss such a possibility here. (Professor Igor Panarin ten years ago predicted a break up of the United States). As Yugoslavia and the Soviet Republics broke off, and now even Scotland examines its ties to Britain, could this happen here?
Final Note, stocks and the oil price appear to be in topping mode for October…