Black Swans Ahead
We
recommend Malcolm Gladwell's Tipping Point as well as Outliers,
add Nassim Taleb's Black Swan. The reader will be on
the way to understanding just how dangerous this environment can
become. For centuries it was believed no Black Swan existed, then one was
discovered in Australia.
The
point of these best sellers is that CHANGE, as the administration likes to say,
can start from seemingly insignificant events.
The
Titanic does not allow for lifeboats as the ship will not sink, on the maiden
voyage a speed record is attempted, the ship scrapes an iceberg, well you know
the rest. Lean the cookie tray one degree too far and the cookies fall to the
floor. Deny the existence of black swans, and whaddya know, the earth revolves
round the sun not the reverse. The earth is round not flat. What is good for GM
is good for America, should we all go bankrupt and presumably come out better for the experience? Indeed
this last bit of syllogistic logic is apparently where we are now.
Unions
support losing Presidential candidates for decades and finally hit gold with
Obama.
Now
as George Will points out, the Federal Government
demands that a bankrupt California pay high wages on a union contract, no
matter the money is not available.
In
a similar vein
Phil
Gramm, as he leaves office, sponsors the Commodity Modernization Act as a
pay off to the finance industry. It repeals Glass Stegall that prohibits banks
from engaging in the securities business. This 1930s legislation was one of the
remedies to prevent risking depositor money in risky financial markets.
Republicans
and Democrats benefit from contributions from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
Believing
all mortgage paper is insured, the entire financial community begins leveraging
'guaranteed government paper to reap even greater returns, why not borrow to
buy a 'can't fail investment?'
Community
organizers and the Attorney General lean on banks to make more loans in
'marginal' read disenfranchised communities, forget the down payment
Markets
go into an upward parabolic swoon, Wall Street types are making millions for
shuffling paper, real estate appraisers get the wink and nod to inflate values,
the value of the paper shuffled rises accordingly as does everyone's take
Where
to get the money, borrow short term in the commercial paper market, previously
reserved for inventory of hard assets, short term debt becomes the ATM
financing long term promises of mortgage re payment.
The
Tipping Point is reached. Richard Fuld, a Governor of the regional New
York Federal Reserve Bank collects $300 M as Chairman at Lehman, Lehman
collapses the next year, Fuld resigns both jobs, FNM and FRE collapse as well.
Numerous
Tipping Points await. California is our largest state, perhaps
number eight or ten in the world, were it a country. Alas, California is
not North Dakota. A failure to pay by California will ripple the municipal bond
market in a way the Administration has not imagined. CA already is
issuing script, play money, for state income tax refunds.
Chrysler
bond holders are not assured of repayment, will anyone invest in Michigan again
as actor Jeff Daniels pleads just that on television?
Ten
states account for 75% of all mortgage foreclosures. Required bank capital is
3% not 10%. Borrow ten to one to
buy leveraged paper and three percent is a flash, not a tipping, point.
The
government leans on GM which leans on the solvent dealers and suppliers
who lean on, well, gee, who is next?
The
seeds of the New Civil War are being sown, the solvent states versus the
insolvent. Here in San Antonio Minnesota based Medtronic is opening its newest
medical operation, hiring 1400. Is there any question why it is in Open Shop
Texas rather than Union Shop Minnesota?
Lots
of White Swans on our lake could turn Black. This column is all about preparing you for the next
sighting of Black Swans posing as icebergs.
We
invite your comments.
Connect
with Dennis Elam at
www.professorelam.typepad.com/markets