Weekend Nov 7, 2015
Per Capital Tax Receipts Top Tick the Stock Market
or as Two Minds put it
The Most Important Chart you Have not Seen

Here is another puzzle piece that the stock market is making an important high. A top in tax receipts has called the top in the market since 1987.
Recall the chart we ran last weekend showing a reliable 394 weeks between market tops, and that has also occurred.
What to Expect Next Year

My academic presentation in Houston was themed that the discounted cash flow model did not adequately explain real world stock market behavior. Indeed social mood is at the root of fluctuations not DCF. The numbers represent the extent of rise and fall in the price of Cullen Frost Bank CFR. Now this is not Gamestop or YELP but a very well managed bank with a solid record of dividends. I was upset that I missed the last bottom in August but then began examining the chart. Since the high of Sept 2014, CFR has moved up and down some 84 dollars, more than the price of the shares today! Yet the fortunes of the bank are unchanged, never a dividend missed. To me this is a microcosm of the wild swings in the overall market which have occurred since July of this year.
Bottom Line If CFR can experience such swings, one can only imagine the volatility in store for less well managed firms with weak balance sheets. Speaking of which...
Valeant

\
Goldman Sachs foreclosed with a margin call selling 1.3 Million shares of the CEO'sVRX.TO stock Thursday Nov 5. It looks like a couple of other margin calls may have preceded that event, note blue arrows. Again the use of credit can truly wreck a stock price once the social mood switch is thrown.
Stocks
NYSE Advance Decline Line

Yes the SPX and DJIA are near their previous highs but that is not he case for the NYSE, Transports, Value Line and smaller indexes like the Russell 2000. So we have a big cap rally going not confirmed by the other indexes.
NYSE A/D Volume

The Advance Decline Volume chart looks even weaker. This speaks to a lack of breadth in the rally though you would never know that reading Art Hill at stock charts.
Dow Theory Sell Signal Still in Force

the 20% plunge int he Industrials and the Transports by August 24 confirmed a Dow Theory Sell Signal. Transports have rebounded not to their former highs but between 38-50%. the MAs appear to be moving together agin. I expect that will take another month or so.Typically MAs converge before a new direction occurs. IF cheap energy prices are a great thing why aren't Transports leading the way back up?
Bonds and Income Related Investments
Five year Yield

The really dramatic rise is on the short end, here is the five year yield. In a bit over a month it wiped out four months of decline. That is a 30% rise since the low in October.
TBF

TBF is an inverse fund to bond prices. It rises with the yield. Recommended.
Utilities

The realization of rising rates knocked the Dow Utilities down 3.84%, Note how Utilities are violently moving up and down like our first chart CFR. Rates are on the rise and it matters not what Janet and the FED does.
REITs

The popular Cohen and Steers REIT was socked for a 4.28% decline as well. The quarterly distribution is 24 cents or 96 cents annually for an 8% return in dividends. Friday wiped out a year of those dividends with a drop of over 4%.
Warning As the FED has kept rates artificially low to help the economy, the FED forced fixed income savers into riskier utilities and REITs. Now as rates rise the principal of those investments is at severe risk as the two previous charts demonstrate. REITs were one of the hardest hit sectors in the 1973-74 decline.
The US Dollar

The big rise in the dollar helped take bond prices, REITs, Junk Bonds JNK and Utilities all down. The race is on to accumulate dollars to pay down world wide debt.
Emerging Market
Shanghai

China has been attempting to 'command' its markets back to growth. Attempts include urging those with no experience with investments to buy stocks and claiming a 6.5% growth rate.
Shanghai Daily

the 38% re tracement is right at the 200 day MA, look for a failure at that level. The Goldman Sachs Commodity Index is at top. The point being we are in a world wide deflationary collapse with interest rates now rising.
Australia

Australia is certainly the most robust of the markets surrounding China. it too is in the grips of the deflationary wave. The 200 day MA also lies just over the price.Note we are seeing the same thing in Shanghai, Australia, and the Dow Transports.
Energy

We now have three failures since the August price low in crude oil. At top unleaded gasoline has been unable to stage any rally which is good news at the pump but no help to the Transport average as noted. The drop Friday was 1.92%. We have been predicting a final low in the mid 30s. It will take a break of 40 to make that happen.
Natural Gas and CHK

The price of natural gas and CHK Chesapeake who produces it are both in collapse mode. A return to the 2012 low seems inevitable.
Gold

Gold is headed towards its previous low amid massive negative sentiment as noted, gold is just a pet rock reads one column in the WSJ. Gold is falling with the same deflationary forces as oil.
The Bottom Line
Friday was an important turning point for interest rates, REITs, Utilities, and Junk bonds. While rates have been on the rise, the action cemented the case. I suspect the highs in all those markets have now been seen. As always the good intentions of low interest rates by the FED have pushed seniors into what are now some of the riskiest investments, REITs for example. As the prices for these securities drop their charts will look like the Valiant margin call we showed. The rush to exit will soon be up on us.
The stock rally is concentrated in the DOW and S & P. Transports, Value Line, Russell are not confirming the rise in the big cap indexes. Hence we are either near a top or the roll over will likely begin prior to year end. Stocks are just now positive again for the year and that is only in the big caps.
The darting in and out of otherwise strong issues like CFR shows how flighty social mood has now become.
Bond prices are falling and will continue to do so.
Oil and Natural Gas are headed lower as is gold.
Commodity based markets like China and the countries surrounding it are falling.
World wide deflation is upon us.
Social Mood
Government ferrets out its own boogey man at market tops. The government sued RCA at the 1929 market top, the tech giant of that day. Clinton sued MSFT near the 2000 market top. IBM came under scrutiny in the 1966 market top. Now the NY state attorney general is declaring opposing climate change to be illegal. His target is the deep pockets of Exxon Mobil one of the largest cap firms in the world. Obama vetoed the Keystone pipeline this week with gasoline prices at their lows. But that eliminates thousands of private sector jobs in the name of dubious climate change, which he fervently believes. Hillary has also jumped on Exxon asking for an investigation.
Shake Shak announced 12 cent quarter earnings. Extrapolating that would be 48 cents for the year. The stock trades at $50 giving this a 100 to 1 price earnings ratio. Wendy's trades at a 34 to 1 price earnings ratio. WEN had $2 B in annual sales for 2014. SHAK had $53 million for the quarter, which would be $212 million or about 10% of Wendy's sales. Yet the market cap for SHAK is $1.6 billion while WEN is $2.6 billion. Here is more proof that stock prices are a result of social mood not discounted cash flow. The stock is surely pricing in every possible good thing that could occur.
Murder rates are on the rise.
The White House denies that both the DEA and FBI director are right on the Ferguson Effect.
Violent crime was a another feature of the 1970s bear market. We are seeing an echo of that same mood with so many big cities run by law enforcement light Dem Mayors. Already murders are on the rise in Blasio's NYC.
Pop Trends Price Culture
[email protected]
The Market Perspective bases its information on techniques and sources that have been found to be reliable in the past, and The Market Perspective tries to base opinions on sound judgment and research, however, we do not guarantee that future results will match past performance ands no guarantee can be made that advice will be profitable. The Market Perspective accepts no money for stock recommendations and is purely motivated by its own research in recommending any stocks. Put another way, the responsibility for decisions made from information contained in this letter lies solely with the individuals making those decisions. The editor and persons affiliated with The Market Perspective may at times have positions in securities mentioned. Nothing contained herein represents an offer to buy or sell securities. The Market Perspective encourages investors to be diversified, and to maintain sell stops and risk control over their valuable investment capital. No guarantee can be made to the accuracy of text or charts.
|