Weekend May 18 2013
Does the FED do more harm than good?
A P/E multiple of 22 is historically rich. But in bull markets stock valuations often go through rich on their way to stupidly high; the S&P's P/E reached 28 at the dot-com bubble's peak in early 2000.
Dot-coms aren't novelties now, and the economy's overall debt burden is higher than back then. Moreover, the Fed has recent experience on how badly things can go wrong after valuations hit stupid levels. So there is a possibility, though no certainty, that it will act sooner to curb excesses.
In the meantime, though, until inflation hits its target, rich valuations are something it can probably live with.
Heard on the Street Weekend WSJ Page B 14
A Look Back at Our Commentary - Weekend November 24 2012
For new readers we exited positions September 18. We began buying partial positions back at Election Time exactly one week too early. We improved by noting mood change Friday November 16, indeed the market has rallied since culminating in Dow 176 points up November 23. We reiterated the similarity between the sell off of March to June with September to November this year in stocks. We remain focused on that similarity. If a rally of similar magnitude, June to September, occurs it would take the SPX from 1340 to 1540. We ended the week at 1409, less than half way there. Commodity stocks rallied this past week.
Since then markets have soared past our 1540 target. But our point is that when everyone was worried about the Fiscal Cliff, we got the turn correct! It is now a near precise six months from that November 16 date.
The first quote from the WSJ Heard on the Street column like many blogs and talking heads, suggests it is different this time and we are headed for higher stock prices. Maybe, but in the meantime what is the bond market telling us? My analogy to 1973-74 is working out well in the political arena. I am beginning to wonder though if we should examine 1987 as an analogy for what might happen if indeed stock prices push higher. Why -
closed end municipal bond funds are starting to trade at a discount to NAV, this one a hefty 3.3% discount
we noted the rise in the thirty year bond yield last week end putting 3.4-3.6% as the resistance yields needed to overcome
the Dollar put on quite a show this week, getting strong sending gold down seven days in a row.
Let's start with The Dollar
The dollar has risen to its highest level in over two years. The black line is the Aussie Dollar which moves quite opposite the US Dollar. At bottom the weekly MACD has room to run before hitting a top.
Weekly Thirty Year Bond Yield
For the third week in a row, yields marched higher. Note the two MAs flattening out. Resistance remains at the 3.4-3.6% area. I noticed this week Barry Ritholtz remarked that one should not be afraid of the stock market as the alternative was 1.8% on the ten year note. Barry has made a lot more money than I have but that sort of automatic assumption that rates cannot rise is typical of turn of the market thinking.
The bond market is typically much more sophisticated than the stock market, it often acts as a DEW Distant Early Warning Indicator something is wrong. We will monitor this development to see if that is the case.
MYD Weekly Closed End Muni
So far this is the biggest correction since late 2010. Is this just a correction or the start of something bigger? Money is moving out of relatively safe municipal bonds and into stocks.
Daily MYD
On the daily chart a neckline of sorts seems to be forming at 15.7 or so. Bond prices move opposite yields so this chart is the reverse of the Treasury yield chart.
1987 Stocks versus Bonds
It was 26 years ago almost to this very day in May. Bonds and stocks both hit a low. Stocks take off into an August high. Bonds tank 16% all the way into October.
Let' lok at just how fast note hields rose in that period of time, and what was the dollar doing?
Ten Year Note Yield 1987
The correlation in dates is truly uncanny don't you think? yields shot up 150 basis points in two months from May. At bottom the Dollar, then as now, was rising. The Dollar and stocks rose into August. the Dollar tipped its hand by heading down after August.
I don't know if this scenario will play out again but I find some of the parallels fascinating. This is worth following. And with October just a short five months out, and August only three months out, we shall see.
The Stock Market
Weekly High Low Indicator
We went back to the Oct 2008 low for emphasis. This indicator is the highest it has been in five years, hardly the way a new bull market begins which is what many are claiming. If this is a new bull market in stocks it would also mean the 18 year cycle has been repealed 13 years in from Year 2000 which I also doubt. but as we saw in 1987 stocks can advance into October.
SPX
Many sites have this same five wave count from the Nov 18 low, exactly six months ago. The SPX is near 200 points over its 200 day MA. Our socionomic take is that consumer confidence has risen to a six year high. This would be in keeping with a new peak in stock prices.
The runaway collapse in gold and silver continues. Gold appears to be in the third wave of a fifth wave of the large third wave if that makes any sense. Multiple readers have sent articles noting that George Soros owns $25 M worth of call options on GDXJ. I am not able to determine the expiration date on those options, If anyone knows or can tell please e mail me.
HUI Gold Bug Index Monthly
The 200 month Moving Average for HUI is right here right now, notice it is just appearing at far right where we put the blue arrow. At far left the 200 month MA is 254.16. Price just overshot that at 246.07. Monthly charts change direction at glacial speed. But the top back in 20110 is clear now. RSI is not as low as on the first move down.
Weekly HUI
With 250 giving way however, I don't see much support here until 150, do you?
An alert reader notes Central Fund is closed Friday at a 5.3% discount to NAV. So we have gold and bonds on sales for less than face value. But the stock market shows no fear...
GLD Two Hour Chart
GLD has not hit bottom yet, MACD still falling on the two hour chart.
HUI Gold Bugs index Ratio to SPX or
It is Blackest Just Before Things go
Pitch Black
The ratio of the HUI Gold Bug Index of Mining Stocks to the SPX has taken out the October 2008
low, This just goes to show that market can get further out of kilter than one ever imagines. It also shows how wildly optimistic the stock market is that the FED has everything under control.
Crude Oil
Crude oil remains in a triangle which could break either way.
The Bottom Line
A six year high in consumer confidence has driven stocks to new highs, just what a socionomist would expect. Investors are exiting the Safe Harbor of municipal bonds. This prompted a comparison with 1987, right to the day when the market did the same thing. We will watch this closely. A collapse in municipal bond prices is something we have been anticipating, and would welcome as a buying opportunity. Gold continues to fall along with silver. Crude oil remains a question mark.
Socionomics
The Great Gatsby was Scott Fitzgerald's signature work. Written in 1925, it was poorly received. Fitzgerald died in 1940 thinking himself a failure. But during the war interest was revived. Today it is rated as a classic American novel. We read it in one of my English classes in college. It has been made into a film version some five times. The latest features as have the earlier versions, the top male stars of the day, not DeCaprio and Maquire. Joe Morgenstern gave it a terrible review last week. But it has arrived at the very top of the market. Fitzgerald wrote the novel reflecting the upscale lifestyle he encountered on Long Island in the early 1920s.
I checked all five. The 1926 version is not rated but this latest got the highest viewer score at a measly 7.5. As with Stephen King it is apparently difficult to bring the written word to the screen.
Still we have to give the producers credit, the timing with a celebration of the 1920s Jazz Age with the
current highs in the market
exotic automobiles priced in seven figures
the return of Mansions formerly Distinguished Properties in the WSJ
endless expensive mechanical watches for sale in the WSJ
peak optimism in consumer sentiment
as bond prices drop
well it's one for the record books.
hanks for reading The Market Perspective
The Market Perspective bases its information on techniques and sources that have been found to be reliable in the past, and The Market Perspective tries to base opinions on sound judgment and research, however, we do not guarantee that future results will match past performance ands no guarantee can be made that advice will be profitable. The Market Perspective accepts no money for stock recommendations and is purely motivated by its own research in recommending any stocks. Put another way, the responsibility for decisions made from information contained in this letter lies solely with the individuals making those decisions. The editor and persons affiliated with The Market Perspective may at times have positions in securities mentioned. Nothing contained herein represents an offer to buy or sell securities. The Market Perspective encourages investors to be diversified, and to maintain sell stops and risk control over their valuable investment capital. No guarantee can be made to the accuracy of text or charts. |