Weekend November 17, 2012
Alan Greenspan has not been right about anything in years. His pronouncement that the markets will be in trouble if the fiscal cliff is not solved are therefore a pretty good assurance that the lows in the market may have been seen Friday November 16. Apparently he has not noticed the market drop already this month.
Plan on avoiding LAX over Thanksgiving. This is a preview of emerging negative social mood that will dominate the news the next couple of years Recall the last era of stagnation ended about 1982with Reagan firing Aircraft Flight Controllers in August of 1981. The next big down move may be preceded with strikes at airports stranding travelers at the worst time of the year and of course hardening attitudes further.
Stock of the Week - jGetting High On Legalized Marijuana MDBX soars 3,000% this week. (Another missed
opportunity.)
Overview
This weekend we remind readers of what makes bottoms and tops, (again, note to self, listen to self) that social mood runs to extremes of risk on and risk off as the saying goes these days, and then examine whether, surprise, the low was yesterday. If so that means our initial purchase was exactly five days
early.
While reams of cyber ink are spilled on 'analyzing markets, college courses claim to teach the true worth of a stock, and all kinds of technical indicators have been invented, in the end it's a simple process.
Stock Market bottoms occur when the selling is exhausted. The last stockholder gives up in a socionomic funk and tosses good companies overboard at bargain prices. Stock Market tops are a sociononic frenzy to join the herd at the top. Investors climb aboard, usually after a prolonged move upward. Once the last dollar is laid on the croupier's table, the buying is exhausted. The top is in, the selling overwhelms the buying and down we go. Now if we can just figure out how to calculate those two events, we can quit our day jobs, right? Well don't do that yet, but we are advancing a series of tools that aid us in that very objective.
Let's first examine our risk on assets. They wil bottom about the time risk off peaks.
The Bigger Picture, The SPX Daily
Stocks got 118 points above the 200 day MA on September 14. Stocks pushed reached their maximum low under the 200 day MA on Friday November 16; As we noted earlier this week, that duplicates the pattern from June 1 shown at far left. Let's move in for a closer look shall we?
We have mentioned on numerous occasions that that quantitative based computerized trading programs are predicated on using a the 200 day MA. That was the reason for the big drop last Wednesday, note the red bar on the chart above. Connecting the dots we later examine where some of that money has been going, into muni bond funds. Our point being that if Mom and Pop investors have not been in stocks anyway, most of the selling was probably computer based as was the case June 1. Could the selling be over?
Hourly SPX
The Boehner Obama announcement came at noon Friday, and pundits were linking the move up in stocks that afternoon with the event. On the other hand, the volume at bottom shows the selling intensified in one last flurry the first hour of November 16. Did the last seller exit at that point? MACD in the center panel turned up nicely. Here is an overall top to bottom tw hour picture of what happened from Sept 14 to November 16.
SPX 2 Hour Chart
Simply put, stocks got too high above the red 200 bar MA and then plunged even further below the 200 bar MA. MACD picked up but it has done that before on the way down. But it can't go much lower at least on this chart. Also note the parabolic nature of the decline. Socionomics holds that the most intense mood occurs at the end of moves. This was clear at the top, and the move down intensified, the slope increased, as this bottom on Friday drew closer.
Is the Fog Lifting, Our Title A Week ago Friday
No the Fog Was About to Close In, Yikes, as a long time sailor I should have seen that coming! Sailing is an excellent analogy to investing. As I will explain in my long anticipated blockbuster sure to be reviewed in Forbes and Fortune E iBook, a sailor cannot make the boat go just where he or she wants. The sailor must make do with the wind and adjust sails accordingly. Investing is the same, the market is going where it wants, do not get wedded to any one theory or scenario.
At any rate here is an update on that chart from a week ago, I think the similarity in the outlined green boxes is remarkable, what do you think? I posted all these charts on Saturday. It is now Sunday morning Nov. 18. I am thinking the time period from now to Inauguration, January 26, will look like the pattern from June to August. We may have an up week going into Thanksgiving. Then as I suggested in an earlier post this week, the lack of resolution on the Fiscal Cliff renders the market in a sawtooth pattern. Some indexes will make new lows, others higher lows. But the Markets start to grind higher.
Let's move in for a really close look at risk off, the Dollar versus risk on, the SPX. We can break Friday down into fifteen minute increments.
UUP Dollar in a 15 Minute Chart
The red black bars are UUP a fund that mimics the dollar. Stockcharts does not have intra day date for the US Dollar itself but we do for UUP. Note that SPX in gray was headed down all week. It moved lower to 1345 by 11:00 AM on Friday. At the same time, UUP made its high at 22.30. Then both reversed. SPX finished the day higher than it began the day. UUP was roughly back where it began the day. While we are at it, let's see
how the VIX performed Friday.
The VIX has consistently formed lower highs, and even registered a lower high when the SPX made a new low Thursday and Friday, then it too fell the last half of the day, just like the Dollar.
Yes this is significant, not enough to call The Bottom but another puzzle piece.
Anecdotally readers of TMP have e mailed saying they would not do anything until after the election so they had no stock to sell. Peruse the news and Mom and Pop have been exiting stock funds for months adn piling into bond funds. An article on page B9 of the Weekend WSJ notes,
Muni Bond Yields Drag on Bottom
Record low yields have been set every day the market has been open this week...on a benchmark scale since the measure began in 1981.
So we know individual investors have now moved muni bond prices to an all time high, that is probably a peak fear indicator. Check out the
Franklin Federal Tax Free Fund
Does that look like a multi-year peak? I think so! Again our point is that perceived risk off investments in bonds and the dollar will peak about the time risk on stocks and gold bottom. Note how steep the rise or slope of the fund is indicating the herding, make that stampeding, of investors into this supposed Safe Harbor.
Regular readers can of course guess where I am going next. Our core belief here lies in following the internal indicators. The extreme high recorded in the High Low Index prompted our exit September 18. Yesterday we noted that one indicator, New Lows, was already at an area which marked the last two bottoms.
NASD New Lows
Given the weakness in Apple and the NASD in general, here is the NASD new lows. Note that as with the last two peaks, this indicator violently reversed the next day. Friday is the red down day.
NYSE Net New highs Lows
Again note the reversal from the very lowest low on Thursday since the high of September.
The summation index for the NYSE and NASD has not bottomed; both are still in decline.
Bullish Percent
This indicator perked up on the 50, 150 and 200 day versions, the last shown here. Think about it, if stocks are in a bull market, by definition they would turn back up at the 50% level. That means half the stocks must stay in bull mode to be by definition in a bull market. That happened Friday.
NYSE Advance Decline Volume
Here is another indicator we have recently used. NYSE Advance Decline volume turned up. And it did so at a slightly higher low than the two previous lows.
MdClellan Oscillator
The Summation Index has not turned up but the Oscillator itself did. My take on these puzzle pieces is that a low of some significance occurred Friday. Clearly we need to see follow through this next week. The week before Thanksgiving is typically an up week, seasonally speaking.
Gold
If the mining stocks fell first, they may likely lead gold back up. The gold trend has not turned up yet.
Yet another alert TMP reader e mailed me this week noting that there were numerous inverse head and shoulder patterns on the charts, she was right, look at this! The trend for gold is not up but if mining stocks led gold down, will they lead gold and silver (shown in gray) to the upside?
GDXJ From Positive to Negative Social Mood in Six Weeks
Here is an excellent depiction of the move from
Positive Social mood mid September to
Negative Social Mood mid November
Green to red, please study this chart, paaste it on your 'frigerator door, as George Strait sang
this is literally what investing is all about , changing social mood,
or as Bill Cosby described his wife when they were dating.
come here come here come here
followed by
get away get away get away
The Bottom Line
I believe a bottom of some significance occurred this past Friday, scan through our charts and comments, whether that is THE LOW remains to be seen but the evidence is in favor of a low.
I said this earlier under the chart with the green box outlines but it sums up this weekend post so here it is again,
Rampant Speculation Our Best Guess
At any rate here is an update on that chart from a week ago, I think the similarity in the outlined green boxes is remarkable, what do you think? I posted all the charts on Saturday. It is now Sunday morning Nov. 18. I am thinking the time period from now to Inauguration, January 26, will look like the pattern from June to August. We have an up week going into Thanksgiving. Then as I suggested in an earlier post this week, the lack of resolution on the Fiscal Cliff puts the market in a sawtooth pattern. Some indexes will make new lows, others higher lows. But the Markets start to grind higher.
Why I Blog
This post is about as long as I suspect most will read. I will add my socionomic comments for the week in the next post, serialized plots are always more fun anyway.
My original objective in starting TMP was to improve my investing by making my thoughts and recommendations public. Since then the number of TMP readers has grown. I sincerely enjoy hearing from you and am quite grateful for those of you that admired my humility in admitting my errors. As one of my broker friends put it
If we were perfect
We'd start a religion
Not a brokerage service.
Mistakes will be made, the difference with TMP is that we admit them and attempt to learn from them. Tell an investing friend about TMP, hey, the price is right. I have described myself as one who makes complex financial transactions understandable. We attempt to do that with every post on TMP blog. We attempt to be informative, entertaining, and hopefully profitable. Our journalistic icons are Tom Wolfe American novelist extraordinaire, and David E. Davis, long time automotive
journalist. I made that comment as a student in a college class to some guffaws from the group that passed for UT Austin MBAs at the time, I was right then and now. The academics have it all wrong, publishing is not about peer reviewed journals that few read, good writing simply means that folks want to read what you have to say. That is our aim at TMP.
Thanks for reading The Market Perspective
[email protected]
The Market Perspective bases its information on techniques and sources that have been found to be reliable in the past, and The Market Perspective tries to base opinions on sound judgment and research, however, we do not guarantee that future results will match past performance ands no guarantee can be made that advice will be profitable. The Market Perspective accepts no money for stock recommendations and is purely motivated by its own research in recommending any stocks. Put another way, the responsibility for decisions made from information contained in this letter lies solely with the individuals making those decisions. The editor and persons affiliated with The Market Perspective may at times have positions in securities mentioned. Nothing contained herein represents an offer to buy or sell securities. The Market Perspective encourages investors to be diversified, and to maintain sell stops and risk control over their valuable investment capital. No guarantee can be made to the accuracy of text or charts.
|
More to Come, See Our Next Post, Don't Miss Out!
Socionomics
LAX
Hostess Twinkies
Fubright Crooker Jaworski merges with, what, an English firm!
Formula One Racimg
Civilization with Nial Ferguson