Sat March 12, 2011
The Mood Change
This weekend we will demonstrate that the US Stock markets have probably joined other markets, which have already turned bearish. As we have said this is a process, not an event.
We will demonstrate that the social mood is turning more negative, an essential postulate of socionomics.
We will review our calls over the last few months.
Our aim here is to prepare, as the Japanese did for their earthquake, for this coming bear market well in advance by taking defensive positions. Those positions will consistently make good money while we await what should be a new low in all major market indices. At that point we will begin accumulating well managed, dividend paying stocks including pipelines, REITs, and various commodity investments.
There is virtually no one on CNBC or in financial publications like Barrons or Forbes describing the beginning of the third bear market since 2000; all are still looking for the latest hot stock.
So let us begin with look at the markets.
Diversification?
Financial planning types endlessly promote the idea of diversification. Their claim is that a balanced portfolio of stocks will withstand negative events. We present the above Chart as Exhibit One in deflating that argument. Here the black and red bars are the Dow Industrials, blue for the NYSE, red for the S & P, and green for the NASD. Note that all are in lockstep having topped the third week in February. This same pattern was evident in 2007 and 2008 as US markets went down and recovered with a three plus month lag to emerging markets.
The Bear Markets Unfold
Purple – A Vanguard Municipal Bond fund double tops in August and Nov, 2010
Red Black – The Bombay Sensex Index tops in Nov after a torrid run from Sept, and then gives back all the gain by February.
Green – the SPX tops in February
Gold– Copper, the leading indicator for the traditional industrial economy tops along with stocks
Now let’s look at how those same markets per formed in late 2008-2008
In 2007, the SPX topped three moths before the Bombay and the municipal funs which peaked in February. Copper was coy, falling and then rising (along with oil not shown).
The lesson here is that all markets do not top at the same time. But we can see that in domino fashion, one after another did fall. Notably commodity markets held up the longest. They were also the first to recover.
On page B7 the WSJ has a story on investing in Emerging Markets. The writer warns that ‘those who bail now could miss some big opportunities.’ There is not a single mention of Ghost Towns in Mongolia, or overbuilt properties from Mumbai to Shanghai. Another long story on China suggests that unlike the Mid East with decades of poor leadership from one dictator, China rotates dictators (calling themselves Presidents of course) every ten years. A new one is due in 2012, he will no doubt have his hands full as the reality of overbuilding real estate comes home to roost.
It is true that Russian ETFs are up while Brazil, India, and China have not fared so well. But Russia is more of an oil and gas play than a real industrial ‘emerging’ nation despite the plans of Putin for a some sort of Moscow Financial Center.
Gold Red – gold hits resistance at 1425
Silver – Silver plays catch up and joins in with a new high
Black – Oil makes a new high, and all appear to be pulling back.
MACD in the bottom panel makes a lower high and appears to turn down
Our point here is that the All One Market Thesis is alive and well with
US Stocks, Gold, Silver, Copper, and Oil were all hitting some sort of combined top this past week.
Now let’s get I our Time Machine and go back to 2008, same markets
Note, this is the chart for 2008. The markets topped in March, just as they are now. The markets sold off for a couple of months. Then oil played catch up and joined the party for the final hurrah in July. Then things fell apart.
This supports our thesis that history will repeat with an echo top in various markets this summer.
The Stock Market
We can be fairly confident that the stock market will not completely tank at this time. First the seasonal high due in May argues against it. Second the weekly summation index, shown below the NYSI, while putting in another recent lower high, is still above its moving averages.
Third the weekly NYSE A/D line is not indicating a top quite
yet. All three moving averages are still headed up. The line has not broken any of them yet. Still we decided to exit stocks a week ago. The rate of change has slowed to near zero and the risk reward is just not there. This is particularly true if all participants decide to exit on the same day as happened last April.
The Weekly SAR PAR has given its first sell signal since the entry generated last summer, note blue dot at the top, far right. The stout Money Flow in the bottom panel indicates plenty of confidence, again this is not over yet. A reasonable target would be the 50% retracement at 1171.4.
Where did the money go?
While Bill Gross was selling at PIMCO, the rest of the market was buying. It will be interesting to see how he spins this. This picture makes our strategy clear. Bonds have not yet ended their thirty-year bull market. This market is stair stepping higher. World stock markets, junk bonds, and municipal bonds have begun stair stepping lower. As always the more sophisticated bond market has taken notice. At bottom the MACD is just beginning to turn up. Note in late 2008 that bond prices peaked as stocks tanked. That is our core strategy idea. We have exited stocks as the risk reward ratio has shrunk. We have recommended entering bonds at another multi-year low.
IEF is a fund of 7-10 year government bonds yielding about 3.2%. TLT is a similar fund of 20 year + bonds yielding about 4.2%.
TLT is short term overbought. Note this is an hourly chart. Stocks are short term oversold, down for the week. We could see some more pullback early this week in TLT and it can still be bought. Note the pattern of higher stair step lows in this hourly chart. This is the process of the market pulling back and finding buyers to substantiate the move up. Note, Bill Gross is finished selling and this chart shows it. The government of course never finishes selling bonds.
Commodity Markets from copper to oil to energy service companies appear to have temporarily topped. This is in line with the All One Market pullback. We are watching for opportunities here. There is still no oil supply interruption. Japan is expected to buy less oil as its refineries recover from the tidal wave. After an uninterrupted move up from last July these markets need more of a rest before another advance. There will be numerous opportunities to play the energy market in short term vehicles like ultra short and long DIG and DUG but frankly we are not set up for readers to adequately monitor investments subject to such radical short term change.
The Market Perspective Record
From the blog, November 14, 2008 on Municipal Bonds
Retirees have crowded into high yield municipals and junk bonds. The result is as usual pictured below; everyone is heading for the exits at the same time as they realize both principal and income are in danger. And it is not just New York and CA that are starting to melt. These charts are screaming, get out, go to cash, and take that extended cruise.
Municipals have since seen record outflows with Congress demanding that Bearish analyst Meredith Whitney explain herself.
From the Blog, March 3, 2011
The inflation adjusted oil price chart shows that the 1980 peak of $36 translates to about $110 in today’s dollars. With oil at $102, that alone is a warning sign. We also noted that Floserve had eleven insider sales and no purchases, adding that the insiders are rarely wrong.
Crude hit a top of $107 the next week and has since retreated.
.
Sunday March 5, 2011
We now officially recommend exiting any long stock positions begun last July. This graph speaks to the lack of a good risk reward at this juncture.
The Dow dropped some 220 points last Thursday and was down over 1% for the week.
Conversely our recommendation to purchase TLT was up over 1% for the week. Bond guru Bill Gross bragged that he had sold all long government bongs from PIMCO’s Total Return Fund. This is high irony, the bond guru in America abandons bonds and embraces stocks as apparently stocks make a top.
Strategy
Stocks, oil, semiconductors, etc have all begun one last pullback before an expected final top the summer. Yes, tops take place at different times. The internals in the stock market like the summation index and the Advance Decline line are not sufficiently deteriorated to signal a mass sell off just yet.
In the mean time the smart money is accumulating government bonds as a safe haven amidst falling markets, which will no doubt be evident by the last quarter of this year.
Our strategy is to establish a safe haven in dividend paying government bonds while most ignore the turn back to the bear phase of the stock market. Again, we noted ina post this past week that the Flash Crash was real, not an accident. We expect more of them late this year and early next year.
Eventually the markets will sink back to March 2009 levels. At that point, we will look to exit our bond purchases at nice profits. We will begin shopping for well managed dividend paying stocks then selling at multi-year lows.
Socionomics is the study of social mood and its results in social actions. It studies how waves of endogenously regulated social mood in turn regulate changes in the economy, political preferences, popular culture, etc.
Positive social mood results in market participation and inclusionary political and social action. Negative social mood results in a lack of market participation and rebellion. The ultimate negative social mood is war.
Now consider a few comments and events from this weekend WSJ.
Unless it is reversed, the administration’s Libya policy will convince the world that the US is a feeble friend and an ineffectual foe, paralyzed by its own ambivalence.
Eliot Cohen, John Hopkins’ Advanced International Studies
EU Leaders Waver on Military Steps in Libya Summit,
US Wary of Libya Role,
Libya Rebels Struggle to Regroup
Even liberal Democrats are unhappy with the Administration lack of leadership in North Africa. But the point for investors, as Cohen points out, is an echo of the failure in Viet Nam. Dictatorships expand into vacuums. Markets dislike uncertainty. The US has injected uncertainty with a lack of a clear policy. History is full of such failure from Chamberlain at Munich to the US waffling in Viet Nam to whatever we are doing in Afghanistan (see Peggy Noonan on Rumsfeld) to calls for help from Libyan rebels. All in all this is about what to expect midway through an 18 year cycle of stagnation, a lack of leadership, reminiscent of the 1970s and 1930s.
Union fight leaves families, co-workers split A schoolteacher considers State Senator Larson a hero, her husband thinks the senator is a coward
Page A3, this is proof positive the New Civil War I have been describing is well underway
The NFL descended into turmoil Friday as negotiations between players and owners broke off. The onset of litigation sends a business that has long prided itself on stability into a rare period of uncertainty at a time of record popularity and revenues. (emphasis added)
This will not help retire the debt on monuments to bull market thinking like Jerry Jones Dallas Cowboys’ $1+ billion new stadium in Dallas.
Lehman Probe Stalls: Chance of No Charges
Not one person has gone to jail as a result of the financial fiascos of 2008. Like the bailout of Long Term Capital Management in 1998, this sends a simple message. If you are going to recklessly gamble with other people’s money, make sure you do it in a big way, so big that the government feels obligated to save you. This will only increase the resentment against Wall Street.
Social mood is breaking down even across the dinner table between husband and wife. Initially the Libyan rebels were going to ‘do it on their own.’ Now they are wondering, where is the US? Note the reversal at the NFL from a top of record proportions no less. This is precisely how tops occur and then reverse.